Tuesday, May 25, 2010

Sometimes Rejection is Nice

Or at least when it's nicely worded. I sent off yet another story (actually the same one that keeps getting rejected all over town) to The Future Fire a short while back, and a few days ago, I got a very polite and encouraging response:

"This was a fascinating and well-written piece, with a dual plot arc of
Alice's failing relationship and imploding scientific experiment
working well to offset each other. Apart from being a parable on
scientific catastrophe-making, however, there isn't much
social/political content to the plot of this story, and in the end we
felt it didn't quite fit what we are looking for in TFF at the moment.

We'd like to thank you again for thinking of us with this story, and
wish you the very best with your writing in the future."


How refreshing to receive feedback beyond the typical form letter! It was also a gentle let-down as to the fit of the piece. I've gotten a few rejections in the past that seemed a little snarky, especially coming from amateur 'zines.

In a way, I was also pleased that the placement of my lesbian protagonist doesn't warrant classification as "social/political content." A mute point someday, I hope? I'm a little ticked with myself that I missed out on the submission window for the theme of their previous issue, Queer Sci-fi, where it may have faired better. Just my luck, I guess.

BTW, the letter also stated that The Future Fire is on hiatus until 2011.

4 comments:

Aika Sumeragi said...

I'm sorry to hear your story was rejected but I'm glad that at least they were nice about it and actually showed they had read it. Better luck next time!
Aika

Brian said...

I'm guessing this is the story you sent for me to read some time ago, which I enjoyed. Keep plugging away.

Utopiana said...

Yes, I think you have read this old yarn about Alice, her girlfriend problems and the pesky wormhole. Sometimes I think I'm too emotionally invested in this story, but I brought those people in the story to life (they made me do it), and I want them to tell their story to a wider audience who may dig it a little.

I've learned a lot this year about perseverance in this field, and I truly was pleased with their response and not downhearted at all. I'm already researching the next potential market.

Penumbra said...

Wow, you are right. That was a very constructive letter amazingly so. I have never had a rejection letter due to the expediancy of never having the guts to submit a project. But if I were to receive one that would be a nice one for sure.